What to do with your textbook highlights
A line beneath a sentence, color beside a definition, a note in the margin: each mark points back to something you wanted to remember. It makes a passage easier to find later. That is useful, but it is only the first step. To learn the idea, return to the passage and work with what it says.
A highlight is a starting point
Highlighting is easy, which is part of its appeal. But it does not reliably improve learning on its own. Dunlosky and colleagues rated highlighting and underlining as low-utility study techniques because their benefits were inconsistent. It is easy to mark too much, or to mark a sentence without thinking through what it means. (Dunlosky et al., Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 2013)
Use a highlight as a note to your future self: return to this definition, claim, diagram caption, or confusing paragraph. It identifies the material to study; it does not do the thinking for you. The distinction is simple: locating information and learning from it are related, but they are not the same task.
Ask a more specific question
When you return to a passage, ask what you actually want to know. “What does this term mean here?” “Can you give me an example?” “Why does this step follow?” Then check the answer against the passage. If it sounds plausible but does not fit the author’s explanation, stay with the source.
There is a useful lesson in a small study by Chi and colleagues. Fourteen eighth-grade students were asked to explain each line of a text about the circulatory system; ten others reread the same text. The students prompted to explain made greater gains from pretest to posttest. The study tested self-explanation, not AI tutoring, but the habit travels well: put the idea in your own words and notice where your explanation breaks down. (Chi et al., Cognitive Science, 1994)
After reading an explanation, close it and try to say what the passage means. If you get stuck, you have a better question to ask.
Try recall before you reread
Once an idea makes sense, see whether you can bring it back without looking. In two experiments with prose passages, Roediger and Karpicke found that rereading helped more on a test five minutes later, while testing led to better retention after two days or a week. Those results come from specific study tasks, but they show why a short recall question can be useful. (Roediger & Karpicke, Psychological Science, 2006)
Try this sequence: mark a short passage, ask a question about it, explain the answer in your own words, then see what you can recall later. Keep the note beside the source so you can find your way back to the author’s words.
What a highlight can tell us
Highlights may also reveal what a reader notices. Winchell, Lan, and Mozer found that patterns of highlights modestly improved predictions of quiz performance for some groups of students in their study. That is evidence about prediction, not proof that highlighting caused better learning or that AI explanations improve it. (Winchell et al., Cognitive Science, 2020)
Keep the passage close
Reader++ keeps saved explanations and summaries with the passage that prompted them. You can reopen the idea there and ask a follow-up while the source is still in view.
Professor